About Our Agency

Sheeley Insurance Agency provides comprehensive insurance options throughout Pennsylvania in Stroudsburg, Milford, Honesdale and Dunmore, including Pike, Wayne, Monroe and Lackawanna counties.

Home » About Our Agency

We are your trusted independent insurance agency.

Your family, your business and your possessions are all important to you, but you may not know how to best protect them. We have the experience to navigate the unique risks you face, serving as your insurance advisor.

We are an independent insurance agency, locally owned and operated since 1933, serving the individuals and businesses throughout Pennsylvania in Stroudsburg, Milford, Honesdale and Dunmore, including Pike, Wayne, Monroe and Lackawanna counties. We offer personal and business insurance solutions, with our specialties in home insuranceauto insurancebusiness insurance and day care center insurance.

As an independent agency we have multiple insurance carriers to help us find the best solutions for our clients at the best price. And being a Keystone Insurers Group Partner, affords us the resources of over 50 insurance companies and the experience and expertise in all types of markets.

Our staff is dedicated to providing you with the best insurance for all your needs, and we believe that each of our clients deserve the utmost dedication, expert advice and personal attention from a trusted partner. As your insurance advisor, we help you make smart decisions—protecting you from the unexpected and planning for the predictable.

elp-lockup

What does Endorsed Local Provider mean to you?

ELP’s are independent agents. We are not captive agents. Independent agents work with many insurance companies. This allows us the ability to find you the best product at the most competitive price.

  • ELP’s are held to a very high standard.
  • ELP’s are accountable on a monthly basis.
  • ELP’s provide fantastic customer service
  • ELP’s are relational.  We want to know why you like Dave so much.  What baby step are you on?

We’re proud at Sheeley Insurance for having 3 of our team members and 1 spouse graduate from Financial Peace University.

Learn More About Dave Ramsey

Our Agency Awards

2020

Became a Dave Ramsey Endorsed Local Provider

2017

Awarded Keystone Insurers Group National Partner of The Year

2016

Acquired The Rodgers Olver Polley Agency
Giving us a larger footprint encompassing Wayne, Pike and Lackawanna counties

2008

Joined the Keystone Insurers Group

Start Quote Request
Choice

As an independent insurance agency we have great relationships with many well-known, reputable insurance companies, giving you the power of choice.

Expertise

Our insurance advisors have years of experience in the insurance industry and serve as your advocate from selecting coverage through filing a claim.

Service

Our insurance advisors have a strong passion for insurance and protecting what you value most in business and in life. We treat our customers like family.

At Sheeley Insurance Agency, our mission is very simple. We strive to provide a true, concierge client experience which is unique in the insurance industry. We give clients the power of choice from top-rated national and regional insurance carriers. We offer comprehensive insurance solutions throughout Pennsylvania in Stroudsburg, Milford, Honesdale and Dunmore, including Pike, Wayne, Monroe and Lackawanna counties.