Skip to main content

Sheeley Insurance Agency qualifies for Mutual Benefit Group’s Inner Circle

Sheeley Insurance Agency Inc., Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania, is one of just seven independent insurance agencies that has received Mutual Benefit Group’s Inner Circle honor based on 2022 business results.

This is the first time that Sheeley Insurance has earned the award.

Mutual Benefit Group is a multiline property and casualty insurance company based in Huntingdon, Pennsylvania. It is represented by 210 independent agents in both Pennsylvania and Maryland. Every year, the Company celebrates the independent agents who have provided superior customer satisfaction while establishing a consistent record of profitable growth.

This group of agents is referred to as Mutual Benefit’s Inner Circle. As part of this group, Sheeley Insurance will be presented with a gift and a cash award at the annual Inner Circle celebratory event.

Sheeley Insurance has been providing property/casualty insurance coverage for both personal and commercial lines of business for 88 years. They currently service Monroe, Pike, Wayne and Lackawanna Counties.  

Agency principals Christopher Lord, president, and John Hollister, vice president, lead a staff of ten people. They say the best piece of insurance advice they have to offer consumers is “work with an independent insurance agent.” Independent agents represent a variety of companies and can choose from among them to provide each client with the right coverage at the best price. Independent agents also serve as advisers and advocates when making insurance decisions and submitting a claim.

In addition to their Stroudsburg location, Sheeley has offices in Honesdale, Milford and Dunmore, Pennsylvania. The agency is actively involved in the communities they serve, supporting a local food pantry, youth programs and the Pocono Area Chamber of Commerce.

Learn more about Sheeley Insurance Agency Inc. at

Skip to content