Team Member

Friendly and ready to help.

Home » About Our Agency » Meet Our Team » Team Member

John Hollister

John Hollister

Vice President & Managing Partner

John grew up in Honesdale PA & currently resides in East Stroudsburg PA with his wife, Amy. They have three grown children, ages 31, 20 and 23.

He began his insurance career in 1996 with Prudential, and became a partner with Rodgers Olver Polley in 2005. That role remains, as R.O.P was acquired by Sheeley Insurance in 2016.

When he’s not hard at work, you can find him on the golf course, riding his bicycle, playing tennis, hiking the Appalachian Trail, or even kayaking down the Delaware River! He also enjoys reading Historical Fiction and has been teaching a men’s bible study for the past six years at East Stroudsburg United Methodist Church.

Start Quote Request

Sheeley Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency made up of exceptional, passionate people focused on protecting you from the unexpected.

Let’s discuss your insurance.

As an independent agency, we offer multiple options at competitive prices.

  • Coverage will not be bound or changed until confirmed by a licensed agent.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.